Showing posts with label US Supreme Court. Show all posts
Showing posts with label US Supreme Court. Show all posts

Monday, April 2, 2012

Health Care Act and Environmental Law

By Johanna R. Thibault, Esq.
April 2, 2012

Last week was a big one in the legal world. Lawyers, politicians, law professors, students, and reporters all crowded the United States Supreme Court building hoping to catch a glimpse of oral arguments scheduled regarding the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, otherwise known as the "Health Care Act," or my personal favorite from the Act's opponents, "Obamacare." Everyone in the United States was closely watching. SCOTUS (Supreme Court of the United States) blog received a record number of blog "hits" during its coverage of the oral arguments with over 800,000 views in a single day. If this tells us anything, it's that we are all listening and anxiously awaiting the outcome of this critical case and wondering whether the Act will survive.

On the table is the Act's constitutionality, and the Supreme Court scheduled three days of arguments to address the following questions: (1) whether the Tax Code allows the Supreme Court to have jurisdiction to hear the substantive questions regarding the Act; (2) whether the Act itself was unconstitutional in regards to the individual mandate; and finally, (3) if the individual mandate section of the Act is unconstitutional, whether the rest of the Act can survive.

The Supreme Court decision on these questions is clearly important in a political realm. As nearly every landmark case before the Supreme Court has effects well beyond its subject matter, the environmental lawyer in me is curious to know: Will the decision have implications to environmental laws and legislation as well?

My discussions with others in the environmental law field lean toward, "no." The structure of environmental legislation in the United States does not appear to mirror that of the Affordable Care Act, although a creative academic exercise could undoubtedly result in some instance where the Supreme Court decision on this case might apply.

So, does this important case and potentially monarch Opinion from the Supreme Court provide anything critical for us environmental lawyers? It just might, in the form, at least, of giving us another window into how the Supreme Court Justices might review environmental law cases that come before it in the next several years.

If the Supreme Court upholds the mandate and sides with the Government, it could be a sign that the current Court prefers to follow pre-existing precedent. In contrast, if the Supreme Court decides against the constitutionality of the Act, we could be looking at a Court of extreme conservatism with an unfriendly eye on future environmental cases.

Is the outcome of this case critical to our country? Absolutely. But we might not need worry much with how the outcome of this case affects environmental law and legislation. Then again, we have been surprised before...